And the winners are...

Gregory Peck (3-1)
















Monty Clift (4-1)



















Jimmy Stewart (4-0)





















...and Cary Grant (2-2... a TIE, which means I cast the deciding vote)

WHO'S CUTER: Jimmy Stewart or Dick van Dyke?

More classic stars, this time of the "aww, shucks" variety. These two both found a place as the lovable "everyman," one on the big screen, and one on (mostly) the small. Yes, Dick van Dyke is just a TV star... which might make him less worthy in some people's eyes. But come on, just look at him. That is one fetching young lad. I think he deserves his place here as much as anyone. But will he make it past the initial round? Or will the similarly cute Jimmy Stewart trounce him? Let's find out.